Posts

Enough freedom to go around (MMO 22 April 2015)

There has been a proliferation of opinions over the recent tabling and passing of the Sedition (Amendment) Bill 2015. The Bill, now an Act, now merely awaits Royal Assent before being gazetted as law. These opinions, mostly negative, have seen some of those opposed to the Sedition Act quote and give credence, as well as much weightage to their arguments based on comparison with the abolition of sedition laws in various foreign countries, in particular the United Kingdom (UK). In this article, the author specifically refers to the response by the United Kingdom & Eire Malaysian Law Students’ Union (KPUM) published in the Malay Mail Online on April 16 titled “How the British abolished their sedition laws.” In gist, the article by KPUM speaks of the British origin of Malaysian sedition laws and does a fair bit of work engaging and expanding on the history of sedition law in the UK as well as how the British have evolved away from their brand of sedition law to enable live...

Use of Jawi should be encouraged, not condemned (MMO 18 December 2014)

Reading the news these days it would seem that we are not short of controversy. As if existing controversies were not bad enough, certain irresponsible quarters have taken to reviving settled issues, such as the Bible Society of Malaysia (BSM) with its sudden expression of indignation over the stamping of Bahasa Melayu Bibles that had been given back by Mais to the Association of Churches of Sarawak (ACS) and claiming ignorance of this fact, in spite of the same having been widely reported in the media when the Bibles were handed over to ACS in the first place. A week ago we were presented with a new controversy and it is over the move by Malacca to make the use of Jawi signage compulsory on all schools in Malacca. An online report by The Star on 11 December has quoted Malacca Chinese Education Progressive Association chairman Yang Ying Chong stating that the Malacca Education Department directly was “unreasonable” and “unacceptable” as the Jawi script did not represent the ident...

Around the World in 8 Sedition Acts (The Malaysian Insider 11 December 2014)

“Restrictions are a necessary part of the ‘right’ and in many countries of the world freedom of speech and expression is, in spite of formal, safeguards, seriously restricted in practice.” – Raja Azlan Shah J, PP v. Ooi Kee Saik In a populist country, it does not matter whether a government’s decision is right or wrong; what matters is that the decision is a popular one, accepted and supported by majority. This is the highlight and the bane of democracy. When Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak announced the retention of the Malaysian Sedition Act 1948, the uproar against the act got deafeningly louder and more aggressive. Sections within Malaysia that wish for a more liberal and freer country flippantly took to the keyboards to churn out miles-long commentaries condemning the decision. In support of their own fear, they brought in “foreign” names sympathetic to their cause berating the move. Many may argue as such but the question in retaining the Sedition Act is not wh...

#DalamBerita: Lelaki diperintah bayar bekas teman wanita RM4,741

Mahkamah Sesyen di Kuala Lumpur hari ini menolak saman fitnah yang difailkan seorang jurutera terhadap bekas teman lelakinya, seorang anggota tentera laut. Bagaimanapun, Hakim Jumirah Marjuki memerintahkan Leftenan Efftizal Hazrie Roslan membayar sejumlah A$1,468 atau RM4,741 kepada Nur Shairah Ishak sebagai pembayaran balik wang yang dipinjamkan kepada ibu bapa Efftizal Hazrie sepanjang perkenalan lima tahun bermula 2005. Jumirah membuat keputusan tersebut di dalam kamar dengan dihadiri peguam Fazlena Noorwati Rahmat yang mewakili Efftizal Hazrie (defendan) dan Fatihah Iliani Jamhari bagi pihak Nur Shairah (plaintif). Fazlena Noorwati memberitahu pemberita bahawa mahkamah tidak membenarkan tuntutan perbelanjaan lain kerana tiada perjanjian sah dan kos akan ditaksir kemudian. Jumlah gantirugi tersebut adalah mengikut tukaran ketika kejadian iaitu A$1 = RM3.23. Pada 30 Ogos tahun lepas, Nur Shairah yang merupakan seorang jurutera dan penduduk tetap Australia memfailkan saman fitnah terh...