Why the Confusion, Aston Paiva? (The Malaysian Insider 28 September 2015)
We refer to the statements made by Aston Paiva as reported in “Ask right questions in secular-Islamic debate on country’s identity, lawyer says,” published in The Malaysian Insider on September 22. Indeed, we agree that in order for the debate on the implementation of hudud to be beneficial, the public must ask the right questions. Participants in the discussion cannot turn it into something that it is not by bringing non-issues to the table. This in turn will allow the discussion to mature, based on solid objective facts, supported by honest opinions for the good of the nation. While we agree that Malaysia practises democracy, the real question worthy of consideration here, is whether the mere fact of being democratic would limit Malaysia’s religious tendency? Flowing therefrom, does it even matter whether Malaysia is or is not an Islamic state? For the sake of the discussion – although we dispute such assertion – suppose one were to agree that Malaysia is not an Islamic ...